Nice place for a nice plaice – Rick Stein’s, Porthleven, Cornwall – CLOSED

When it comes to the TV, Rick Stein is one of those people who is seemingly always doing one programme or another (Mexico is his next BBC jolly apparently). Unlike with the Hairy Bikers or Jamie Oliver, I actually quite enjoy watching Rick Stein’s programmes. With Rick Stein, there are no laboured wisecracks or mockney gibberish and he is seemingly happy to just talk about and cook food. 

His “Weekends Away” series packages together three of my great passions in life (after Mrs. SF and the dogs of course) in the form of food, drink and travel.

From his original base of Padstow, having turned it into Padstein, Stein seems intent on total Cornish domination. He has an astonishing 10 restaurant, cafes and pubs dotted around Cornwall, with a further 4 places outside of Cornwall including a recently opened gaff in London  (after allegedly vowing he would never open a place there) in Barnes.

One of his many premise in Cornwall is located in, a favourite spot of Mrs. SF and I in terms of holidaying in the UK, Porthleven. 

On our last visit to Porthleven in December we plumped for dinner at Kota over Rick Stein’s but with Mrs. SF and I back in Porthleven we though we would give Rick Stein’s a go this time. We therefore booked in for a Wednesday night, with the added bonus of Mrs. SF treated me to dinner.

The place 

A lovely building on the harbour side which, prior to Stein taking it over, looked set to slowly fall into disrepair or become apartments.

Inside it is very nice, with an open kitchen as you walk in (plus lots of Stein merchandise) and a cosy area by the bar with leather sofas.  I would hazard a guess (could be wrong – often am) that Stein senior has never actually cooked a service in this place, with his son (I believe) heading up the kitchen brigade.

There is a mezzanine level, but we were led to a glass fronted area looking out over the harbour. For the Summer and al fresco dinning there is an outside terrace area.

Bit bracing on day of our visit for a fresco dining regrettably.

The food 

The menu is much more limited than that at Stein’s flagship premise in Padstow and the menu has a more bistro feel to it. It is also reflective of Stein’s travels (courtesy of the BBC).

Whilst perusing the menu we had a plate of kalamata olives (£2.95)  Great with a glass of Lustau Puerto Fino ( £4.95 – a favourite of Mrs. SF’s). 

The briney olives went perfectly with the ozone rich Puerto Fino.

For starter I was torn between the mackerel fillet and the fish soup. I plumped for the soup as I think a fish soup is a good test of the mettle of a kitchen which specialises in fish. If it gets fish soup right you are in safe hands for other fish dishes, but if they bugger up the soup you know you are in trouble.

The soup here is a pretty darn good one. Rich and thick, it had a lovely depth of flavour to it (that only comes from using a proper fish and shellfish base stock). It came with a really punchy rouille and some parmesan, with made for a very satisfying dish. My only complaint was I could have done with a couple more of the croutons, with 3 seeming to me a bit mean for the £7.95 price tag.

Mrs. SF went for the beetroot cured salmon, with pickled cucumber. A nice cure (quite light) on the salmon was complimented by a touch of earthiness from the beetroot, with the pickled cucumber worked nicely to cut the richness of the salmon. A well thought out and executed dish

On to the mains, whilst the menu has meat options, to me it would be perverse in a place owned by a chef famous for his seafood and with fish and shellfish in its title to go for anything other than something from the sea. Odd mind that out of the 8 mains only half are seafood.

Again mackerel tempted me, but I am a sucker for a decent bit of plaice cooked on the bone. Very underrated fish, in my opinion, the plaice.

What I got was a very nicely cooked piece of quality fish, which came away easily from the bone. Nice to see they had properly trimmed it so as to get shot of those fiddly skirt bones.

I liked the addition of peppers, garlic and oregano, which gave the dish a Mediterranean feel. Bit more, however, of them would have been nice.

I polished it off, leaving very little on the bone 

At £16.95 I thought it fairly priced but do think it could have had with it some dressed leaves or a bit more of the peppers (the plate looked a bit bare with just the fish and 3 spuds on it).

There is a bit of gentle upselling re the sides and with the lack of much else, bar from the fish and spuds, on the plate I ordered the spinach and pancetta salad (£3.75) which took my main to over the £20 mark. I enjoyed the spinach and parmesan, but did find the pancetta in balsamic a bit sweet. Personally I thought the balsamic had been a little over reduced.

Mrs. SF went for a fish curry in the form of Goan Cod curry (£14.95). A spicy rather than hot curry it was more shy on the coconut front (excuse the pun) than I was expecting, but had a good flavour to it. The fish was perfectly cooked and wasn’t overawed by the spicing. 


The accompaniments were some perfectly fluffy pilau rice and a chapati. The latter was a bit of a surprise as I tend to associate (probably wrongly) the chapati with Northern India and the pao/pav with Goan Cuisine. Mrs. SF branded it a pleasing, if perhaps slightly pedestrian on the spicing, dish.

Despite being quite full, we both opted for a pud from the interesting sounding dessert menu.

 My initial thought was to go with the riz au lait, with spiced pineapple, which sounded rather nice. I was, however, swayed by the lure of the salted caramel ice cream and peanut butter crumb that came with the chocolate pavé.

Nicely rich (but not cloyingly so) chocolate pavé, with the star of the show being a really good salted caramel ice cream. The only disappointment was the crumb, which was a tad lacking in the promised peanut butter flavour.

Mrs. SF went traditional with her pudding choice with a ginger pudding (coming with clotted cream ice cream). Decent sponge, with plenty of ginger, but crying out for custard rather than the clotted cream ice cream (nice as it was – weather was regrettably more Autumnal than Summery on the day of our visit) that it came with. 

I did think the latter an odd dish to have on what I assume was their Summer menu.

The drink

On the booze front there is a reasonable selection and it is always good to see sherries on a list, especially a Puerto Fino (a rarity on lists in the UK) which we had as an aperitif.  Shame the sherries are not available by the bottle, as they are such good food wines rather than just being an aperitif.

As a whole, the list seemed a bit pricey to me with some serious mark ups in the mix.

£42 for a Carquexial Albarino when it retails at Nicholls and Perks at around the £11.50 mark (nothing like what Rick Stein’s place will have paid for it I can tell you) makes for an eyewatering mark up.

After much humming and harring, I went for a bottle of Picpoul de Pinet from the Languedoc. Great fish wine this, with nice lemony flavours (think lemon peel and lemongrass) and some herbal notes.  

Worked very well with the plaice and had enough about it to cope with the mild spicing of the fish curry. Very pleasant wine to drink with fish or on its own. Tad pricey I thought though at £32 (difficult to track down retail, but have seen it at around the £8 mark so looking again at a pretty hefty mark up here). 

With the desserts we had a 10 year old tawny Port from Quinta de la Rosa (£6) and a Domaine de Grange Nueve 2009 Monbazillac (£5.95)  Both pleasant enough, if a bit pricey on a per glass (75ml for the Port and 100ml for the Monbazillac) basis.

The monbazillac was all barley sugar and marmalade, perhaps a bit light for either dessert, whereas the port was a good match for the chocolate based desert (nutty and figgy, with a hint of the medicinal about it).

I did find the pricing of the two wines on the dessert menu a bit odd. An £18.95 bottle price for the Samos Muscat equated to £5.25 a 100ml glass price ( 28% of the bottle price) whereas a £31.50 bottle price for the Monbazillac came in at £5.95 per glass (19% of the bottle price). This seems to me to make the Samos disportionately and unfairly pricey on a per glass basis.

The verdict 

Mrs. SF and I enjoyed our meal at Rick Stein’s. Nothing fancy pants, just good honest cooking.

The bill did seem to add up a bit, coming out at a smidgen under £120 (we did have a fair bit of booze mind)

This is a similar price to what I would regard as Rick’s main competitors in Porthleven, Kota.

Would I go back? Yes – as the title suggests it is a nice place which cooks a nice plaice. 

I do, however, wish they would have on offer some specials which take advantage of the fact that Porthleven is a working fishing port. There is nothing on the menu that suggests they utilise stuff coming from the Porthleven fishing community which to me is a great shame and a wasted opportunity.

A specials board utilising what day boats, operating out of Porthleven, bring in would to me be a nice touch and make the menu less formalaic.

My other slight whinge about the place (not the plaice) is the wine mark ups are a little bit on high side I think. The food pricing seems fair, the wine pricing much less so.

Due to this its prices are on a par with Kota’s (whose food is a bit more pricey,  but they mark up their wine less) and Kota is in my opinion overall a better option for a one blow out/celebration meal in Porthleven (food there is more adventurous and sophisticated that at Stein’s). Rick Stein’s is, however, definitely a nice additional/alternative option if you are in Porthleven. 

They do do an lunch/early bird (before 18.30) set price menu, which looks to be quite good value for money.

It is also a shame (particularly with Chalky) that it is not dog friendly, but there are plenty of other dog friendly options in Porthleven if you are holidaying down there with your doggies 

Since my visit there has been a fire at this place (on the 11th June). Luckily no one was hurt and the damage seems to have been pretty limited. It has already reopened it seems.

Here’s hoping that the recently opened Seafood Shack in Cardiff is able to cook fish to the standard of this place and Kota in Porthleven. Mixed reports to date, have to say, but will pass judgement in my own good time.

The details


Mount Pleasant Road, Porthleven, Helston, Cornwall, TR13 9JS

Tel:  01841 532700

Website: click here 

Twitter: @steinporthleven

Opening hours: Lunch : 12:00 – 15.00; Dinner: 17:30 – 21:30



  1. In some ways I find this review a bit mean-spirited: ‘I would hazard a guess…that Stein senior has never actually cooked a service in this place’, has Jamie Oliver cooked a service at every one of the places with his name on the door? ‘Inside it is very nice with …lots of Stein merchandise’. True, but it’s incredibly nice Rick Stein merchandise with some really lovely ceramics. Ironically, you could have had more or less the same meal you had from the set menu for only £21.50. I know that’s only served until 18.30 but it’s a great bargain, as is Sunday lunch which I can really recommend. In terms of the comparison with Kota I think you should go back and check their prices. Starters are an average of about £9.5, mains about £21.5 and dessert £7.95. Last time I ate there 3 courses with a couple of glasses of fizz, a bottle of mid-priced red and coffee was closer to £150. A fairer comparison might be the Square which, like Kota, has a Bib Gourmand but the pricing is closer to Stein’s. Anyhow, suppose we should be grateful that our favourite place in Cornwall has at least three great places to eat. By the way The Tolcarne Inn in Newlyn is unbeatable if you like fish.


    • Thanks for the comments – I am afraid as a lawyer my day job involves being a bit mean spirited so perhaps it leaks out into the blog. I do try to be honest and constructive. I ate at Kota in December last year (and had a look at the menu this time and prices now looked comparable to then) The price at Kota for 2 was £129 – 3 courses (brill dish was one of best fish dishes have had) × 2 with wine (a better wine but cheaper than one at Stein’s) dessert wines and gin and tonics and a coffee (didn’t have later at Stein’s). I think price wise they are much of a muchness and certainly on basis of the food I personally think Kota is worth the little bit extra. Not that I didn’t enjoy Rick Stein’s place and said so in the review. Do wish they had a specials board though using Porthleven day boat catch. I agree wholeheartedly that Porthleven is very lucky on the food front – As said, it is one of my favourite holiday spots in the UK. Cheer for the tip re the Tolcarne Inn . Dog friendly also it seems so double whammy for me😀


  2. Hi SF, I enjoyed reading this review. Lines in the comments reminded me of the only time Mr Tss and I dined in a Norwich restaurant bearing a celebrity name. It was a Friday night… Christmastime…the restaurant serving an Italian menu was absolutely heaving with people. Our expectations were riding high. But our crab pasta mains were just full of bits of shell, The balance of elements – all wrong. The meal was quite horrible in fact, and the bill was quite expensive. So when we came to pay and were disingenuously asked if everything was okay, we stated that it wasn’t and the reasons why. The waitress looked back blankly and said she’d pass our comments on to the Chef. I assumed it wasn’t Jamie Oliver doing the evening shift that night. Ha!


    • Sound rubbish, but have only ever eaten at that chain once and didn’t enjoy at all so your experience no surprise. More people should complain in restaurants if have legitimate issues, but just not the British way it seems. I thought the food at Stein’s was pretty good and would certainly go back.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s