A rather rosey repast, with naught to grouse about? Medlar, Chelsea, London

Little known fact (well at least to me) is the medlar is part of the rose famiIy and it also happens to be the name of a quite highly rated restaurant in London. Having looked at the menu at Medlar, it suggested to me a rather rosey outlook for anyone who happens to be considering eating there. 

It has become a tradition of the Cardiff Wine Buyers Club to have an annual jolly to London in November which aligns with the Decanter Fine Wine Encounter and we like to make a proper weekend of it.

The festivities are required to start off with a very boozy lunch on the Friday, with what we need for the venue being:

  • good food;
  • reasonable corkage; and
  • reasonable good value (not the same as cheap).

The order above is not necessarily the order of our priorities, but as we are all wine fanatics the corkage is an absolute must.

Having these priorities in mind we decided (after a false start with 10 Greek Street booked and then it sadly shutting up shop in a worrying sign of the times) upon Medlar in Chelsea which has:

  • a good reputation for quality food (Andy Hayler rates it and that tends to be good enough for me);
  • its three course lunch is £57, which whilst not cheap looked to be very fair value (based on the online menu); and
  • they are very amenable to corkage (£20 a bottle at lunchtime, with no limit to bottle numbers per table).

We are a group that is quite obsessive about wine and it was one of the group’s 50th (sadly not mine as I past that milestone back in AD 43 fighting the Romans) so we decided this warranted pushing the boat out a bit in terms of the wines we bought for the occasion.

Not a bad selection I have to say, with the 1999 Cepparello and the 2017 Inniskillin Vidal icewine (love a sweetie) being my contributions.  

As we perused the menu, we kicked off wine matters with the fizz, in the form of a Boizel, with a nice bit of age (2008).

Lovely nose of bruised apple, with nice toasty notes and bright citrus fruit on the palate. I don’t drink a lot of fizz, but I rather liked this with its very gentle mousse.

The menu is a thing of beauty

with an distinct Francophile feel to it.

It is nice to see a prix fixe menu with plenty of choice (7 starter, 7 mains and 7 puddings) on it and rather admirably the only supplement was for cheese (which based on the pics of the cheese board I have seen seemed fair enough)

Things kicked off rather nicely with an octet of gougéres (£2.25 a piece).

which had a please hit of nutty cheesiness from an aged comte centred filling and a nice soft choux. These were excellent with the champagne.

Bread was a reasonably diverse offering from a basket, with the focaccia the clear favourite

Nice and light with a crisp salty crust and a soft airy interior (good salty butter too). I liked that they kept it coming with the starters and mains.

For starters, I was instantly drawn to the duck egg tart, with its showcasing of seemingly humble ingredients in the form of turnip and duck heart.

Nice crisp pastry base was filled with a beautifully smooth turnip puree, which wouldn’t know a lump if it punched it in the face and had a nice earthy sweetness and touch of pepperiness (as well as just a soupçon of turnip bitterness) to it.

The egg was nicely cooked, with the rich, creamy, yolk running into and enriching the robust red wine sauce (a good bottle went into making it I would wager) which was spiked with an abundance of crispy lardons and nutty (with a pleasing touch of bite) enoki (I think) mushrooms.

The stars of the show in terms of this dish were the duck hearts, with their rich meatiness amping things up nicely. Big bold flavours on displayed here, but nothing was too dominate and it all worked together.

Lovely stuff and a very decent portion size for a starter.

The rest of our party opted for the crab ravioli,

which again was a very robust portion size. I didn’t try any of it, but it went down very well with those that did. No stinting on the primary crab ingredient, which is always nice to see, a good (i.e. not much) thickness to the pasta and the plate awash with an excellent bisque sauce (so I was told).

We paired this with a Meursault 2021 from Olivier Leflaive.

Lovely butteriness to this wine as well as citrus notes, with a refreshing acidity and a nice minerality.

Worked a treat with the crab ravioli (for those that had it), but still have enough oomph to cope with my rather robust duck dish.

I rarely see grouse on menus in the places I tend to frequent and when I do I invariably order it as it is a rare treat to eat the king of game birds. It featuring on the menu was, therefore, an instant go to for me.

The bird here was served as two breast fillets and we were warned it would be rare (to which my faux Scottish response was “absolutely nae bother”).

Lovely rich gaminess to this, with heathery herbal notes, and a delightful sweetness to the ruby red meat.

Top notch accompaniment, with a bread sauce heavily infused with clove and nutmeg, a rich patê made from the bird’s offal (sitting on a bit of fried bread) and a robustly gamey jus. Peppery watercress worked very well as against the sweet and sour of the damsons and what was advertised as a potato galette, but was more a tuille/jumbo game chip type affair to my mind, had a nice crunch to it. 

Great dish this, with a lovely balance and the bird rightly the star of the show,

Two of us ordered the grouse whilst another dish ordered was a cocquelet (much ribbled conversation was had before it was found to be a juvenile cockerel),

with some rather fine looking crepé parmatiers (new one on me, with potato puree added directly into a light batter apparently), a stuffed leg and a plethora of veggies.

Good crispy skin to the chicken, which is a must for me, and use of dragoncello (Italian for tarragon apparently) to make a quite chunky (such that it was a quinelle) accompanying sauce.

The final main ordered was a advertised as an under blade fillet, which is not a cut I am particular familiar with to be honest.

Excellent bit of well flavoured meat, cooked on point, with a good sauce, spiked with blobs of shallot puree. A portobello mushroom operated as a table top for some snails slathered in cafe de Paris butter and what I think were croutons. Only thing I didnt see on the plate was the (as advertised on the menu description) bearnaise (was it one of the bigger pale blobs on the plate?). 

In hindsight, I think we missed a trick by not ordering a side or two of their triple cooked chips with bearnaise (£6.50) as there were no pots with the steak (which looked to be crying out for some chips) and a pretty minimal potato element with the grouse.

As with the starters, the main delivered excellent flavours and generous portion sizes (even with the paucity of the spud offering).

Wine wise we paired two bottles with the mains.

First up was a red Burgundy in the form of a 2015 Gevry-Chambertin from Pierre Naigeon

Lovely drop this,

with a heady mix for dark and red fruits as well as a pleasing freshness. 

Great pairing with the grouse I thought.

The second wine with the mains was a Cepparello 1999.

Remarkably youthful in appearance,

Actually pic from when I corovin’d it the day before, to check still ok, rather than in restaurant (was enjoying too much so forgot pic) where the glassware was a lot better.

this still had that trademark sangiovese acidity, with cherry as well as chocolate, espresso and leather on the nose. The palate still had fruit in the mix, with cherry as well as more tertiary notes. 

I would say this wine is peaking nicely now.

Worked with all the mains but probably excelled the most with the beef, whereas the gervey (as a classic combo) favoured the grouse.

On to puds, I went for the roasted plums with ginger cake number.

Really nice spiced plums and a very good vanilla ice-cream were the pluses. The negatives were the ginger cake was just a touch dry and I wanted more of the stem ginger puree. Nice, but the weakest of my three courses I thought.

Other deserts includes a well received raspberry cheesecake,

which looked a bit 70s to me, and a very good dulce de leche stracciatella ice cream with cinnamon beignets

In hindsight, I rather wished I had chosen the latter dish over my plum and ginger dessert.

We finished off the wines with a sweetie from Canada in the form of a 2017 Innskillin vidal icewine.

Absolutely fabulous wine this,

with ripe stone fruit (nectarine), mango and honeyed tropical fruit. It was gloriously  sweet, but had a lovely core of citrus acidity that made it refreshing rather than cloying.

Coffee (£7) and good petite fours

finished things off nicely.

The verdict

I thought the base price of £57 for 3 courses, with the quality of ingredients and how they were used, represented excellent value. I suspect just the grouse dish, in many a posh London restaurant, would be not far off the three course price here.

Service was excellent, attentive but unobtrusive (they just magically appeared when you had a thought you needed them, but otherwise left us alone). They were particularly good with the wine we bought, with different and well suited glasses provided for each wine and everything served at the right temperature.

Little things like a plate of lemon slices and a caddy of ice with the tap water brought to the table were also welcome touches

To my mind, good service can (at least partly) save an otherwise mediocre meal, but bad service will ruin even the best food. Here it was all spot on.

What made the meal amazing value was their £20 a bottle lunchtime corkage offer. The 5 wines we bought would probably cost combined £500+ if bought retail today and I suspect north of a £1000 if bought off a restaurant list with UK mark ups applied. As such, taking into account the £100 corkage we paid, even if we had paid the retail price now for the wine (which we didn’t, with me for instance having bought the cepparello and the Innskillin icewine on or soon after release and as a result at a price a lot less than what they retail for now), we saved ourselves a bucket load of cash.  I often rail against wine prices in UK restaurants, which I think are increasingly becoming unaffordable, but corkage offers me the opportunity to drink very fine wines when eating out at a pretty affordable price. Increasingly and to my mind regrettably, it is becoming the only way I can afford to drink good wines when eating out.

I like to think we did a rather fine job with the wines we bought in terms of pairing with the food we had.

The bill for 4 of us (with a very well deserved tip – I forgive them it being automatically added as service was excellent) was just over £105 a head.

For that we had a cracking meal with some really stellar wine and the rest of our party had the added benefit of my syntillating company and witty repartee (which I would say was worth their respective portions of the bill price alone 😂). As such, money very well spent.

If you want a very good lunch in London, with a very fair corkage offer then I would say Medlar should fit the bill (and not an overtly big one either) very nicely.

As I understand it Medlar had a Michelin star up until 2015, but then lost it and has not regained it to date. How the Guide allocates its coveted “stars” is a bit of a mystery to me (and I suspect I am not alone is that confusion), but I have eaten in a fair few starred places and I would say Medlar was better than at least some of them. If the lack of a star (deserved or not, on the basis of the Guide’s rather arcane and very opaque criteria) keeps the prices reasonable then I am all for it to be honest. 

I strongly suspect we will be going to this place again for next year’s jolly as it pretty much perfectly met our needs.

Details

Address: 438 King’s Road, Chelsea, London, SW10 0LJ 

Website: https://www.medlarrestaurant.co.uk/

It made for a rather fine start to a very, very boozy weekend in London.

Leave a Reply